By the Chapter, Day 1 | Mother of the Believers: A Novel of the Birth of Islam by Kamran Pasha
Welcome to By the Chapter. This week’s featured book is Mother of the Believers: A Novel of the Birth of Islam by Kamran Pasha. Sharing hosting duties with me this week is Nicole from Linus’s Blanket.
***
If you’re not familiar with Mother of the Believers: A Novel of the Birth of Islam here’s a little background on the book fromFSB Associates:
Deep in the desert of seventh century Arabia, a new prophet named Muhammad has arisen. After he beholds a beautiful woman in a vision and resolves to marry her, the girl’s father quickly arranges the wedding. Aisha becomes the youngest of Muhammad’s twelve wives and her feisty nature and fierce intelligence establishes her as his favorite. But when Aisha is accused of adultery by her rivals, she loses the Prophet’s favor—and must fight to prove her innocence.
Pardoned by her husband after a divine revelation clears her name, Aisha earns the reluctant respect of Muslim men when their settlement in Medina is attacked and she becomes a pivotal player on the battlefield. Muhammad’s religious movement sweeps through Arabia and unifies the warring tribes, transforming him from prophet to statesman. But soon after the height of her husband’s triumph—the conquest of the holy city of Mecca—Muhammad falls ill and dies in Aisha’s arms.
A widow at age nineteen, Aisha fights to create a role for herself in the new Muslim empire—becoming an advisor to the Caliph of Islam, a legislator advocating for the rights of women and minorities, a teacher, and ultimately a warrior and military commander. She soon becomes one of the most powerful women in the Middle East, but her passionate nature leads to tragedy when her opposition to the Caliph plunges the Islamic world into civil war. The women of Islam view her as a hero, but Aisha is filled with uncertainty and regret whenever she considers her legacy.
***
Before I even started this book my interest was piqued beyond my usual love of historical fiction because I’d received an email from Fauzia Burke, President of FSB Associates thanking me for featuring Mr. Pasha’s book. I found this intriguing and thought there must be more to this particular book than meets the eye. After visiting the author’s website and reading some of the posts there I began to gather that Mother of the Believers might be a book to spark discussion. Because Mr. Pasha has chosen to write about Islam and Muslims, a religion and people steeped in controversy, he has stated that he expects there will be readers and scholars who will take issue with his portrayal of these events. OK interesting so far and maybe a bit daunting but most certainly not deterring. For me knowing this is a time and place in history peopled with characters that I have only the vaguest familiarity with I gave very little thought to his concerns. While I could certainly try to understand them I didn’t feel that I should let those concerns interfere with my reading. For more read his blog post, Why my novel might shock you.
I think Mr. Pasha might able to offer a unique perspective on these events. When authors are writing historical fiction they must rely on available documentation of the events and interpret such to fit their story. While this is the case for Mr. Pasha he also can offer the readers something the vast majority of writers in this genre cannot and that is a solid grounding in his subject matter. As stated by Mr. Pasha in the Author’s Note: For the record I am a believing and practicing Muslim. Theologically I consider myself a Sunni, and spiritually I am drawn to Sufism, the mystical heart of Islam.
***
I’m approximately a third of the way through the book. To this point the story has focused on the beginning, or birth, of Islam and a young female child, Aisha, who is destined to be the future wife of the Prophet Muhammad, may God’s blessings and peace be upon him. The Muslims have been persecuted and driven from the city of Mecca by Quraysh tribal leaders (it was the tribe to which the Islamic Prophet Muhammad belonged, as well as the tribe that led the initial opposition to his message) who fear that the teachings of Islam will bring down their way of life. The background of Islam is interesting and the author does a nice job of framing the story for what is to come later.
It may be because I’m not really into the heart of the story yet but I haven’t come across any subject matter that I would consider controversial. I’m really just enjoying the story and absorbing the events surrounding the first Muslims. As with any topic at hand in the world today you will have your hardliners gracing either end of the spectrum. You’ll also have fanatics, conservatives, liberals and those who fall somewhere in middle. My lack of knowledge may be a blessing in this case as I can just sit back and read without any prejudices and presupposed ideas to hinder my journey. I’m looking forward to reading more about Aisha, as she assumes the role of Mother of the Believers. It appears that her odyssey won’t be easy and she’ll falter along the way.
***
If you’ve read, or are currently reading, Mother of the Believers: A Novel of the Birth of Islam please share your thoughts with us.
***
This week’s reading scheduling:
Monday: The Printed Page
Tuesday: Nicole from Linus’s Blanket
Wednesday: The Printed Page
Thursday: Nicole from Linus’s Blanket
Friday: The Printed Page/Nicole from Linus’s Blanket



This is a topic that I’m painfully ignorant on too. Can’t wait to see what you think when you’ve finished the book.
So far it’s been very interesting. Lots about Islam I don’t know. I’m starting to get more into the heart of the story and things have picked up.
[...] Marcia opened up with a wonderful background on the book and the controversy that it was expected it to cause, as well as her own thoughts, here. [...]
Great job with the introduction Marcia. I must confess that I am having some problems with the book. Learning about the culture is definitely very interesting. I don’t think that I ever really thought of Islam/Muslims as being evangelical, but there seems to be some of that as the Prophet seeks to spread the word and questioning and challenging people to examine their religious beliefs.
I think that some of the controversy from what I have read as I have searched online is the age of Aisha, the marriage age and consummation, and arguments for and against Mohammed being a pedophile. Several places seem to have some sort of documentation of Aisha herself saying that she was 9 at the time that she was married. In this story she is presented as marrying at 9, and I thin other sources have her at 13. I am a little squeamish about reading about her playing with her friends and toys and then the next minute having the veiled references to seduction and their more intimate moments. I know that these types of relationships and age differences are historically accurate, so I am trying to stay seeing it as the filter of the times ,
The other part which was difficult at first was keeping track of the tittles. They called The Prophet by three different names, and then it was The Uncle of the Prophet who of course had other names. It was hard for me to keep track of all the characters when each of them were called so many different things. I am about a third of the way through the book as well, and I feel that I am finally able to settle in and enjoy it a bit more. There is so much hinting at what is to come next that I am very curious about what will happen.
Thank you. Neither had I given any thought to the evangelical part but I’d guess to start a new religion you’d need a way to spread the word to potential followers. And in those days the only way to do so was by personal contact. No Internet or blogging back then.
I’ve read a lot of historical fiction and in order to understand where the characters are coming from you have to frame your references to their time and place and not substitute modern day beliefs. Her age doesn’t bother me because in those times that was widely accepted behavior. Also it’s a committed relationship, one she truly believed in and, according to history, envisioned by Muhammad and ordained by Allah.
Keeping track of the characters is certainly a task. I continually find myself getting them confused. And the naming conventions don’t help any. I liken it to the royals families. All those Williams, Charles, Richards, Marys, Annes and Elizabeths can get a bit confusing. I think the author does a fairly good job of helping out by referencing relationships periodically.
I saw this book and thought it would be an interesting way to learn something of the subject or at least point me in a direction to do my own research.
I think when you read a book concerning other cultures, you have to learn to accept things for what they are and do not judge. There is an anthropological term for it, and it’s escaping me at the moment.
I look forward to reading all of your thoughts.
I agree. You do have to remove modern era beliefs and values and place yourself within the context of time and place. Just because we’ve chosen not to accept certain behaviors in this day and age doesn’t mean that we should impose those values upon these characters. Some of the behaviors we frown upon today were the very means of survival in an earlier time.
Jenny – my copy of this book is looking for home once I’m done reading it. Let me know if you’d like my copy.
Why that is so kind of you Marcia! I would love to take you up on your offer. Thank you so much! Drop me an email. and thanks again
I have this one. I am excited to read it. It is a culture that I am ignorant about… to find out about far away places and different cultures is one of the best things that I have found that reading can provide for me.
I can honestly say that I’m enjoying this book. I can’t judge it against anything else because I haven’t read any other books about this part of world history. It is keeping my attention because Aisha is such an interesting female character and she plays a large part in Islamic history.
I’ll be interested to hear your thoughts. I’ve heard some of the controversy surrounding the novel, and haven’t been sure if I wanted to tackle it. I’ll enjoy hearing your take!
Honestly I haven’t come across much that strikes me as controversial but then I’m not Muslim nor do I practice the religion. My Wednesday post will tackle some of the points Mr. Pasha raises that he views a potential hot buttons.
[...] week’s reading scheduling: Monday: The Printed Page Tuesday: Nicole’s blog, Linus’s Blanket Wednesday: The Printed Page Thursday: [...]